Speak Up! - View Question #17518

« LawForKids.org home page | « Go back to speak up question #17518

Question: Can school administrators question a student about drug use in the school without parent permission? After ditching school the principle questioned me until I told them who I thought used drugs, is this legal?

Answer:

There is no law that prevents a person from asking another person a question. However, in some cases there are rules. Police officers are allowed to question people as part of investigations of criminal offenses. There are limits to that ability. If a person is a suspect in a case, an officer should tell them of their "Miranda rights." that they have the right to remain silent and the right to have an attorney present before questioning. If the officer fails to advise them of these rights, and if a judge later decides the statements were taken improperly, the judge can refuse to allow the statements to be used in court.

Where the suspect is under age 18, the officers should be careful to advise the child of his or her rights, including the right to have a parent present during questioning. The officer should be careful not to intimidate the child during questioning. A judge can decide later that the child was questioned improperly, and that can result in the statements being thrown out. If the judge decides the questioning was proper, the statements can still be used even if the child wasn't advised of their rights. Each case is different, and not all judges rule the same way on the issue of whether a specific statement was taken illegally. It would be a good idea, if you have been questioned, to discuss this issue fully with an attorney who is familiar with all the facts of the case.


Comments
1 thru 3 of 3 comments
On 01/22/08
from AL said:
can a child under 18 be questioned or even serched without a parent present
On 01/07/08
from TN said:
That is the question I want answered too. Is it legal for school administration to question a child and obtain a written statement, with the intent of using it against the child, without a parent present. Especially if the parent has been notified and is en route?
On 11/15/07
C from IL said:
He didn't ask about police questioning, he specifically asked whether it was legal for a school administrator to detain students and question them with no lawyer present and without reading him his Miranda Rights, and I'd like to know. IS it legal for school employees to detain and question students without obeying any of the requirements the police must obey?
1 thru 3 of 3 comments



Read more about the law and School
Related Stories
Related Laws
« LawForKids.org home page | « Go back to speak up question #17518