Speak Up! - View Question #172

« LawForKids.org home page | « Go back to speak up question #172

Question: Are parents allowed to lock children in their bedrooms? If so, what is the max amount of time allowed?

Answer: Parents have the right and the duty of care, custody and control of their children. They may do whatever is reasonable to exercise their right and duty. The question is whether their action is reasonable and it depends upon the facts of each specific circumstance.

Parents certainly cannot lock a child in a bedroom and then go out to a party. That would place the child in an unsafe situation and would constitute child neglect.

It would probably be unreasonable to lock a child in a room without bathroom breaks for too long a time, or where there is no fresh air, or where there are dangerous fumes or other threats to the health and safety of the child. They would also have to be certain that the temperature in the room was reasonable, and perhaps that water was available. It would probably be unreasonable to lock a child in a room without light, at least in the daytime.

One would also have to consider how often this occurred, and for what reasons the child was locked in their room. If this is the only way that a parent can get this particular child to sit down and do homework, and it only occurs every school day for one hour, it might very well be acceptable. There is no specific law in Arizona regarding acceptable conditions. The matter would be up to a court to decide whether the parent's actions were reasonable.


Comments
16 thru 20 of 21 comments
On 12/25/02
Bryan from OH said:
If the child did something really bad than that is understandable.
On 11/04/02
Cassy from MN said:
I think that in some circumstances that it would be better for a child to be locked in his room. I know a child who is 8 and has severe behavioral problems. He wouldn't think twice about tearing down the walls. In a situation where the parent is afraid what they may say or do will harm the child yes it is better they be locked in a room until the parent or the child calms down. Being locked in a room for no reason at all, unlawful and cruel but for good reasons I feel is fair and the child should really look at it as a way to relieve a harry situation for the time instead of a punishment. Peop
On 11/02/02
n/a from AZ said:
all this *childrens rights* hogwash is why kids think its ok to go to school and blow away their friends. its time to bring back corporeal punishment!!! kids are not adults and they do not need the same rights and privilages as adults.
On 10/13/02
mike from HI said:
Why not? What do kids do for parents? Do you pay rent? Food? Gas money? Taxes? What is it that children contribute but gripes, complaints and heartache? A dog would never do so and I'd lock him up if I needed too. Personally I don't condone such behavior as there's a certain amount of risk and damage that can be done to a child. But as to children having rights? When I meet the child that does things RIGHT, then I'll become an advocate for "Children's Rights." The constitution makes allowances for many things, even individual happiness. It amazes me how often kids fail to realize th
On 09/01/02
MMM from AZ said:
i think it should be unconstitutional!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
16 thru 20 of 21 comments



Read more about the law and Family
Related Stories
Related Laws
« LawForKids.org home page | « Go back to speak up question #172